FINAL DOCTORAL PROJECT

Doctoral Project Artifact
by Brother EDEN Douglas / JAKES DIVINITY SCHOOL via George Fox University
LEADERSHIP ETHICS & ACCOUNTABILITY:
From Pathology to Purpose

Fostering integrity and accountability in leadership practices.
PROLOGUE

In this project, pathologies refer to recurrent, diagnosable patterns of harmful beliefs, character, and practices in leadership — such as narcissism, abuse of power, moral disengagement, secrecy, and revanchist control — that deform leaders and systems from their ethical and theological purpose. These pathologies are not treated as isolated personal flaws. Still, as intertwined psychological traits (e.g., Dark Triad), distorted theologies of power, and toxic organizational cultures that produce systemic ethical failure and collective harm, this leadership project emerges as a culmination of sustained theological, historical, and ethical reflection on how power can drift from vocation to violation, especially in church and faith-based contexts.
Drawing together earlier coursework, biblical exegesis,
and case studies of ethical collapse, the project frames leadership failure not as an aberration but as a recurring human and institutional vulnerability that requires intentional, structured response. The prologue sets the tone by naming both the pain of betrayal and the promise of transformation, insisting that
addressing toxic leadership is a spiritual imperative grounded in the imago Dei, prophetic critique, and restorative justice. By situating the work within a wider journey from pathology to purpose, it invites readers and practitioners to see themselves as participants in a communal process of repentance, reform, and renewed witness.

The JOURNEY
In 1996, I lost my modeling agency in New York City because of hubris and drugs.
I did not know it then, but that was the genesis of my interest in why failure happens to those who have worked and planned so
fervently for their success, only to lose focus and succumb to clichéd pitfalls at the height of their achievements. This project’s journey traces a movement from initial questions about failedleaders to a robust theological, psychological, and sociocultural account of why ethical breakdowns occur and how they can be transformed.
It moves through Scripture’s portraits of fallible leaders, historical episodes of revanchist power like Jim Crow, and contemporary corporate scandals to show that the unethical side of leadership is both ancient and urgently current. Along the way, encounters with Ubuntu, feminist and Afro-communal ethics, and restorative models such as South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission deepen the vision of what accountable leadership can be. The journey thus becomes both intellectual and spiritual, inviting leaders to confront their own shadows and to imagine new structures that protect the vulnerable and honor every image-bearer.

DISCOVERY Phase

In this phase, the project identifies the NPO (Need, Problem, Opportunity) by naming the persistent, multifaceted phenomenon of ethical failure in leadership, particularly when personality traits, organizational culture, and systemic injustice intersect.
Through biblical narratives of Saul, David, and the Pharisees, and through case studies like Enron, Theranos, Jim Crow laws, and mass incarceration, the research uncovers recurring patterns of hubris, moral disengagement, secrecy, and revanchist control.
Interdisciplinary literature on the Dark Triad, hubris syndrome, and moral disengagement further clarifies the psychological mechanisms that enable leaders to rationalize harm while preserving a positive self-image. This phase concludes that leadership failure is rarely about isolated “bad apples” but about deep structural and
spiritual distortions that demand comprehensive, theologically grounded interventions.
DESIGN Phase

The design phase translates these insights into a coherent, theologically robust framework and project concept aimed at accountability and healing. Biblically, it weaves together imago Dei, sin, cross-shaped power, ecclesial participation, and key texts such as Mark 10:42–45, Micah 6:8, Acts 2–4, and 1 Corinthians 12 to articulate servant leadership, mutuality, and restorative justice as non-negotiables in Christian practice.
Theologically and ethically, it integrates Ubuntu’s communal vision, feminist and womanist theologies, and global responsible-leadership discourse to design a model that centers shared power, prophetic witness, and institutional safeguards.
This phase culminates in the conception of a
mixed-methods documentary project that embodies and communicates these design commitments through narrative, visuals, and lived examples.
DELIVERY Phase
The delivery phase focuses on implementing the doctoral project as a documentary that investigates the unethical side of leadership while showcasing pathways to reform. Structured in segments—from opening historical montages, through psychological analysis and toxic cultures, to African ethical paradigms and accountability practices—the film is designed to move viewers from shock and lament toward critical understanding and hopeful action.
A carefully staged production process (pre‑production research and scripting, filming interviews and case studies, post‑production editing, and public screenings) serves as the vehicle for translating scholarly findings into accessible, affective storytelling. In this way, the delivery phase embodies the project’s conviction that confronting toxic leadership must involve not only academic analysis but public education, communal dialogue, and practical imagination for change.
BENCHMARKS
We are dedicated to establishing a culture where accountability is ingrained in leadership practices, fostering transparency and trust. Benchmarks in this project serve as theological,historical, and methodological markers indicating progress from diagnosis to transformation.
Scripturally, benchmarks include moving from seeing leadership as status to embracing Jesus’ redefinition of greatness as servanthood and shared participation in the body. Historically, milestones such as the Truth
and Reconciliation Commission and Ubuntu‑inspired initiatives demonstrate that institutions can embed restorative justice and communal accountability into
their structures.
Methodologically, the completion of the proposal, literature review, research design, and documentary outline serves as academic benchmarks that ensure the project remains rigorous, interdisciplinary, and oriented toward concrete outcomes for communities facing leadership harm.
CHALLENGES & KEY LEARNINGS
The project identifies several layered challenges in addressing the unethical side of leadership, beginning with the deep entrenchment of narcissistic, authoritarian, and revanchist patterns in both secular and faith-based institutions. Leaders and systems often resist scrutiny, minimize harm, or spiritualize authority in ways that silence victims and shield perpetrators, making corporate repentance and reform difficult. Theologically, there is the challenge of recovering neglected biblical resources—such as prophetic critique, feminist readings, and Afro-communal ethics—in contexts shaped by patriarchal and individualistic traditions. Practically, translating complex theory into documentary storytelling also requires navigating access to archives, securing honest testimonies, and presenting painful narratives with integrity, nuance, and pastoral sensitivity.

Key learnings from this work include the realization that Christian theology, properly engaged, offers not only critique but also constructive resources for reimagining leadership as shared, accountable, and restorative. Scripture’s honest portrayal of failed leaders, combined with doctrines like imago Dei and the cross, reframes power as responsibility and calls communities to embed structures of mutual discernment and correction. Intercultural dialogue with Ubuntu and feminist models demonstrates that communal, participatory, and justice-oriented leadership is both biblically faithful and globally resonant.
Finally, the process reveals that storytelling—through documentary film—can function as a form of public theology, helping communities name hidden wounds, see systemic patterns, and envision new practices of ethical, servant-hearted leadership.

Home

Posts

Find Us

Contact

Doctoral Project Artifact

by Brother EDEN Douglas / JAKES DIVINITY SCHOOL via George Fox University

LEADERSHIP ETHICS & ACCOUNTABILITY:

From Pathology to Purpose

PROLOGUE

DESIGN Phase

Theologically and ethically, it integrates Ubuntu’s communal vision, feminist and womanist theologies, and global responsible-leadership discourse to design a model that centers shared power, prophetic witness, and institutional safeguards.

This phase culminates in the conception of amixed-methods documentary project that embodies and communicates these design commitments through narrative, visuals, and lived examples.

DELIVERY Phase

BENCHMARKS

We are dedicated to establishing a culture where accountability is ingrained in leadership practices, fostering transparency and trust. Benchmarks in this project serve as theological,historical, and methodological markers indicating progress from diagnosis to transformation.

Methodologically, the completion of the proposal, literature review, research design, and documentary outline serves as academic benchmarks that ensure the project remains rigorous, interdisciplinary, and oriented toward concrete outcomes for communities facing leadership harm.

CHALLENGES & KEY LEARNINGS

This phase culminates in the conception of a
mixed-methods documentary project that embodies and communicates these design commitments through narrative, visuals, and lived examples.